How to Identify Which KPIs Are Least Likely to Be SMART?

Not all Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) are created equal. Some fail to meet the SMART criteria (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound), rendering them less effective for performance measurement. Here's how to identify the least SMART KPIs:

  1. Vague Objectives:
    E.g., "Improve customer satisfaction"
    Why it fails: Lacks specificity and measurability
  2. Unmeasurable Metrics:
    E.g., "Enhance company culture"
    Why it fails: Difficult to quantify objectively
  3. Unrealistic Targets:
    E.g., "Achieve 100% market share"
    Why it fails: Not achievable for most businesses
  4. Irrelevant Indicators:
    E.g., "Increase social media followers" (for a B2B industrial supplier)
    Why it fails: May not be relevant to core business objectives
  5. Open-Ended Timeframes:
    E.g., "Reduce costs over time"
    Why it fails: Lacks a specific time-bound element

SMART Score Formula:

SMART Score = (Specificity + Measurability + Achievability + Relevance + Time-boundness) / 5

Each component is rated on a scale of 1-10. A score below 7 indicates a potentially weak KPI.

Example: Transforming a weak KPI into a SMART one

Instead of: "Improve customer service"
Use: "Increase customer satisfaction score from 7.5 to 8.5 within the next 6 months"

For an in-depth guide on crafting SMART KPIs and avoiding common pitfalls, explore our resource: Mastering SMART KPIs: From Vague Metrics to Strategic Performance Indicators.

Go up